Try runescape. I've played like about 1 year (last login was 114 days ago lolz), and I still haven't beaten the final quest (dragon slayer, lvl 110 monster that does 60 dmg ranged if you dont wear anti-dragon breath shield). Although the movement and battle system are kinda weird, you can fish, mine ores, smith the ores (therefore making your own gear), cook, use magic, you can steal (member only), make bows (member only, non-memb get short,long bow's + crossbow + pheonix gang crossbow only), make potions (strength pot is non member, rest are member). Theres diff type of fishing gear, diff types of food, diff types of magic, theres "auras" that effect you only.
Main member stuff:
Tons more quests, more than 2x non memb.
Dragon gear (dragonstone, dragon weapons + armor)
3 new fish (Lava eel + Shark + Bass)
Tons of new monsters (strongest is lvl 199, king blue dragon)
More spells avail for usage (still displays on non memb, but cannot use blood rune and 1 other rune)
Still more, just cant remember what.
www.runescape.com