Thanatos - I hear you on the growing up in the Evangelical dogma. I spent 8 years in private Christian (not to be confused with Catholic) school. The transition from that to a rather large public high school was traumatizing, to say the least.
I certainly don't agree with much that organized religion puts out there, but there is still part of me that is willing to believe in the supernatural. I refuse to believe that we're here as a species, operating on these intellectual and creative levels, simply because of some genetic mishap millennia ago. Not to say that I don't agree with evolution (the evidence is clear). Creationists are a bit...off. I'm going to leave it at that.
Threaded Mode