The stats aren't always the same. Look at SYG's then mine.

Mine has Skill recharge and casting speed, SYG's has only casting speed.

Also SYG's has two Health +30, whilst mine has two Armour +5.

If only you could attack the people whilst doing the mission for Galen Trask. I walked around the whole of SF and had to stop myself screaming with frustration at all the bosses yet not being able to kill!