The only rules are that you can't flame another member and you can't spam. His initial post seems fairly well-thought, regardless of whether or not it's bullshit. He didn't post a string of obscenities or jibberish, so it's not technically spam.

On top of that, even if he made all that nonsense up, it's still got a structure and an argumentative base. You can still debate the outcome of the fight, it's just based upon the standards that he has set as opposed to the standards set by the game. That's lame and stupid, but not against the rules.

I can't, in good conscience, close this based on the fact that it's lame. If that was the case, I'd be closing threads left and right in the rest of my forums.