Why is a science forum wrong?

We've attempted a couple of scientific debates here... One that I can think of was a self-proclaimed black hole expert mentioned time dilation, and I so kindly ripped his statement into tiny pieces and pissed on them. He never posted here again.

I think with some activity, input, and intelligence, it would be great.


(By the way, a physical impossibility does not count as a technicality.)

What is it they say about silence being golden?