Why didn't you ask him why he didn't flame in the flame forum? I guess the rules should only apply to certain people. You see that is the type of thinking that made you a piss poor game master. Next on the topic you can get someone whacked even if they have run out of guardzone if the damage they did to you occurred in the guard zone and they are visible. For example, someone casts explode on you and starts to run out of guards and you start to run after them if the spell hits you while you or your packy is in guard zone and when this happens you can still see them and yell guards they will get whacked whether they are in guards or not. Shouldn't an ex-Gm be aware of this? Another reason in the long list of why you should be in charge of nothing.