This is a toughy. They both have amazing reply value, and we all know that Halo is so damn fun, but so is KOTOR. I can't really decide. Lol, it's funny because Halo and KOTOR are the only games I'm playing ATM. I've beaten them both countless times (All three diffucultys for halo, and Light Side and Dark side for KOTOR), but I still play them. I'm going to have to go with Halo though, especially cause of multiplayer (ever have a party where theres like 4 xboxes and 4 TVs and you have a mass team game and the best part is you can't look at the other team's screen) and the fact that KOTOR will eventually become boring (until downloadable content comes out).

I'm gonna have to go with Halo.

JMBA Technical Solutions. For all your technical needs.