Well I don't have anything good or bad to say about Everquest Online. I've never played it, however I have played Phantasy Star religiously on the Dreamcast. The only pros and cons are that for the Playstation 2 I already have a network adapter and keyboard. For the GameCube I do not.

Thanks for your help everyone. I kept Phantasy Star, and just happened to find an adapter for my GameCube as I was going to buy Everquest Online. Because I've had just as many people tell me to buy PSO as I have EQ I just decided that I'd demand my mom to buy EQ for me. Including Metroid Prime which I got yesterday, Zelda which I'll get in a month, PSO, EQ, Gun Valkyrie, and Herdy Gerdy (I finally found this yesterday!) I won't be buying any games until at least June.